Words by Jorge Villazon-Leon, M.IRHACE, General Manager of Air & Odour Management New Zealand
Commercial kitchen design: Cleaning the exhaust air using electrostatic precipitation
Electrostatic precipitators offer an effective solution for cleaning exhaust air in commercial kitchens, capturing grease, smoke and fine particles to reduce health risks, odours and environmental nuisance.
Commercial kitchen effluent typically contains vapour, grease, particulate matter (PM), volatile organic compounds (VOC) and polyaromatic hydrocarbon (PAH). Some of these compounds have been found to be detrimental to human health.
The general approach is to use a stainless steel hood to capture and contain the effluent, incorporating grease filters and using a fan to transport the contaminated air to the outside via a duct network. The discharge is in a vertical direction and complies with regulatory minimum distances between outlet and inlet and adjacent boundaries.
An important point indicated in the AS1668.2-2012 refers to the discharge not creating ‘nuisance’ or danger to health. Although this term may appear subjective, its effect may be perceived differently by many people. It may include external deposition of grease/oil in adjacent buildings, unpleasant odours or undue exposure to people.
Some situations require effluent treatment, including instances where physical limitations preclude discharge above the highest point of the building or where vertical discharge is still likely to cause nuisance. Typical situations would include horizontal discharge and vertical discharge in a built-up area.
Electrostatic precipitation has successfully been used to clean the effluent to a high filtration level.
HISTORY
The first commercially available electrostatic precipitator was patented by Cotrell in 1907. But centuries passed before the electrostatic phenomena could be fully understood. The earliest encounter with electrostatic attraction has been credited to Thales of Miletus (Greece), who noted that rubbing a piece of amber attracted small fibres. In Greek, the name ‘amber’ is translated as ‘elektron’, which then became ‘electricity’.
Contributors to the development of the empirics behind the electrostatic phenomena include the work of William Gilbert (1600), Stephen Gray (1732), John Canton (1754), Faraday (1832), and Coulomb. The latter was responsible for developing the equation that determines the force, either of attraction or repulsion, between two charges.
Earlier experimental work using electrostatics was carried out by various authors, including Hohlfield, who cleared fog from air in a container in 1824; Guitard, who removed tobacco smoke from a gas cylinder in 1850; and Nahrwold, who demonstrated in 1878 that electrical discharge from a sharp point increases dust collection.
Accounts of the first efforts by Walker and Hutchings in 1885 to develop a commercial version at a smelter indicate that this was not successful. The reason for this was twofold: the difficulty in dealing with lead fumes and also the lack of sufficient power.
THE PRINCIPLE OF OPERATION
As the air containing cooking effluent enters the electrostatic precipitator, this becomes ionised due to the presence of a high-voltage electrical field, typically of the order of 12-14 KV. Particles, solid or liquid, contained and suspended in the air, become electrically charged, which then migrate to the plates with opposite polarity having lower voltage, typically of the order of 6-7 KV (refer to Figure 1). Particulate collected, including oil, drops by gravity to the collecting tray below (refer to Figure 2).


COMPONENTS
An external view of a ducted type electrostatic precipitator is shown in Figure 3. The electrostatic precipitator cell (ESP) and its parts are shown in Figure 4. An ESP is constructed of aluminium plates incorporating stainless steel springs and ionising wires. The main electrical and electronics components include Hight and Low Voltage Wires, a High Voltage Board, Relays, and a PC Board.


Apart from ducted electrostatic precipitators, extraction hoods with built-in ESP cells are commercially available in New Zealand.
Figure 5 shows a rendering view of an extraction hood with built-in ESP cells and an ozone generator.

PARTICLE SIZE AND COLLECTION EFFICIENCY
To assist in visualising the size of the various components that make up cooking effluent, human hair diameter is used as a measure, having a median value of 69-89µm (Loussouarn, 2016).
Commercial kitchen exhaust hoods are generally fitted with grease filters of various collection capacities and types, ranging from 100 per cent to 58 per cent at 10µm. At 5µm, their collection efficiency could range from 20 per cent to about 98 per cent. Depending on the type of grease filter and type of cooking process, a great proportion of the effluent will not be collected by the grease filters and will be either deposited within the hood internals, duct surfaces or expelled to the outside.
Alternatively, electrostatic precipitators can collect particles ranging from 0.1µm to 10µm (Ling A).
Table 1 shows a sample of test results on an electrostatic precipitator at an airflow of 472 l/s and resistance of 23 Pa as per ASHRAE Standard 52.2-2017.

Airflow entry velocity and uniformity are important considerations as they are directly related to the migration velocity of the charged particles when moving towards the collection plates. When the velocity is too high, particles have greater momentum and overcome the electric field attraction. Figure 6 shows the relationship between axial velocity (entry velocity) and migration velocity for various particle sizes. For those particles, the maximum migration velocity was achieved when the axial velocity was 2 m/s. Therefore, maintaining air on velocity within this value and making sure the air is equally distributed across are important considerations.
Figure 7 shows the changes in collection efficiency and pressure drop associated with an increase in airflow velocity.


The Air Pollution Engineering Manual (Environmental Protection Agency, 1973) states that an increase in axial velocity results in an exponential reduction in efficiency and, in the same way, a reduction in velocity increases efficiency. Uniform air distribution through all sections of the ESP is therefore of equal importance.
The benchmark particle size for rating filter collection efficiency is 0.3µm. The reason for this is that this particle size is the most challenging particle to arrest and is referred to as the most penetrating particle size (MPPS). The US Department of Energy developed this filter rating benchmark for HEPA (High Efficiency Particulate Air) filters.
At the ultrafine level, which is <0.1µm, particles move in a random pattern due to collisions with gas molecules. This behaviour has been called ‘Brownian motion’. In a HEPA filter, particles smaller than 0.3µm can be collected due to this phenomenon.
The accepted rating criteria for a minimum filtration efficiency is 95 per cent at 0.3µm, and this is also used to rate electrostatic precipitators. In an ESP, smaller particles hold reduced electrical charge, resulting in lower collection efficiency; however, the diffusion Brownian effect counterbalances this, allowing the minimum particle collection of 95 per cent at 0.3µm to be maintained. This threshold should be used when comparing the collection efficiency of different brands.
MAINTENANCE AND SERVICING
Efficiency and satisfactory performance of electrostatic precipitators can only be achieved and maintained through regular cleaning of the ESP cells themselves and internal parts of the surrounding cabinet, including prefilters. In addition to cleaning, it is recommended to monitor pilot lights, voltage and amperage. Frequency of cleaning depends principally on the type of cooking process, length of cooking time and operating hours. Servicing this type of equipment must be carried out by personnel who have had adequate and appropriate training.
There are two types of maintenance strategies: preventative and predictive (AIRAH, 2019). The latter involves monitoring the conditions to ensure equipment reliability. Frequency of cleaning can be established by initially monitoring grease build-up on the collection plates over a period of time and then settling on a particular frequency, such as monthly, bimonthly, six-monthly, etc. Predictive cleaning maintenance may be a suitable approach in the case of electrostatic precipitators.
Poor maintenance will result in an increased fire risk, premature equipment failure and costly repairs. Damage to electrical components can be the result of poor cleaning practices.
When high filtration is required, for example, horizontal discharge, the requirement of maintenance should be mandatory (AS668.2-2012, 2012)
AIRAH standard DA19 includes a section on maintenance of electrostatic filters. Although this may be generic, it should be used in conjunction with specific manufacturer’s recommendations and equipment characteristics.
ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES
Advantages:
- High collection efficiency, >95 per cent at 0.3µm.
- Low power consumption, about 0.17 w per l/s.
- Low pressure drops 20 Pa to 50 Pa, depending on air velocity and level of collection build up. In comparison a HEPA filter can have an initial resistance of 250 Pa and a final of 500 Pa.
- Can be arranged in modules to suite heavy effluent load.
- Can be integrated with other mitigating technologies such as ozone generation or UV treatment.
- Minimal moving parts.
Disadvantages:
- Initial capital expenditure, although it may be the most appropriate solution.
- Electrical safety consideration.
- Requires trained personnel for cleaning and servicing.
SUMMARY
The physics of electrostatic precipitation is well developed, proven and understood. Technologies using this process have been commercially available since Cotrell patented the first electrostatic precipitator in 1907.
There are many instances where the solution to commercial kitchen particulate mitigation is required. For example, when exhaust duct cannot be extended beyond the roof level, or when distances from air intake and point of discharge cannot be met without treatment, or simply when the effluent is causing nuisance. Nuisance can still be created if discharging vertically. Typically, in the form of oily deposits, smoke and odours affecting property or people. Notwithstanding this, there is abundant literature confirming that exposure to cooking effluent affects human health.
Owning an electrostatic precipitator is a valuable asset. End users should have a satisfactory maintenance regime in place. Unfortunately, in many cases, less than optimal maintenance is carried out due partly to cost and partly due to a misguided understanding of the importance of maintenance.
Designers of the ventilation system should take into account the required limits on air velocity entering the ESP and ensure uniform distribution, and also make provisions for adequate and safe access.
When selecting an electrostatic precipitator, consideration should be given to collection efficiency at 0.3µm, robustness of the ESP cells, for example, plate thickness, ionising voltages and the availability of local technical support.
Footnotes
- Ultrafine (<0.1 micron), Fine (0.1-1 micron), Coarse (>1 micron)
- Hydrocarbons, alcohols, phenols, aldehydes, ketones, n-alkanoic acid, n-alkenoic acids, carbonyls
- CO, CO2, NO2, SO2
- AS1668.2-2012 section 3.10.2 (c)
- Air Pollution Engineering Manual, Second Edition, p137
- Air Pollution Engineering Manual, Second Edition, p135
- Air Pollution Engineering Manual, Second Edition, p137
- Ecolibrium , April 2018, Volume 17.3, pp 44-52
- Data from a locally available brand.
- Ecolibrium April 2018, Volume 17.3, p 48
- Named after Robert Brown after he discovered this particle behaviour in 1827.
- Ecolibrium, March 2018, Volume 17.2, p38
- Section C3.10.3.3
- Section 19.2
References
AS668.2-2012. (2012). The use of ventilation and airconditioning in buildings Part 2: Mechanical ventilation in buildings. Sydney: SAI Global Limited.
Environmental Protection Agency. (1973). Air Pollution Engineering Manual (Second Edition ed.). Los Angeles.
Ling A, Z. R. (n.d.). Commercial Kitchen Hood Exhaust System and Standard Development. University of Sydney, School of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering, Sydney.
Loussouarn, G. L. (2016). Diversity in human hair growth, diameter, colour and shape. An in vivo study on young adults from 24 different ethnic groups observed in the five continents. European journal of dermatology.
The Australian Institute of Refrigeration, Air Conditioning and Heating. (2019). DA 19 HVAC&R Maintenance (4th Edition ed.). Melbourne: AIRAH.




